The Lamentation after Hugo van der Goes

A composition
that the market knows well

For five centuries, copies of this lost composition have changed hands across Europe's great auction houses. Each sale tells us something about what a panel like this is worth — and to whom.

n.d.
Gazette Drouot · Lot 70
La Deploration — vers 1520

Entourage of Quentin Metsys

La Deploration — vers 1520

Oak panel, parqueted · ornamental gold ground

One of the earliest documented copies in private hands

Apr. 2016
Hampel · Munich
Deposition of Christ

Circle of Hugo van der Goes

Deposition of Christ

82 × 55 cm

Oil on oak panel, parqueted

Same support, same attribution, same subject as this painting

Est. 40,000 – 60,000 €

May 2019
Bernaerts · Antwerp
Lamentation of Christ — fragmentary

Copy after Hugo van der Goes — XVI/XVII c.

Lamentation of Christ — fragmentary

52 × 63 cm

Panel

Fragmentary copy after the lost original. Lot description cites: Ghent MSK (56 × 43.6 cm, inv. 1951-M), Bruges Sint-Janshospitaal (65 × 82.5 cm, inv. SJ0190.I), Amsterdam Rijksmuseum (84 × 105 cm, inv. SK-A-4488). Sold below estimate.

Est. €2,000–3,000

Realised: 1,700 €

Jun. 2023
Hampel · Munich
Deposition — ornamental gold ground

School / Follower of Hugo van der Goes

Deposition — ornamental gold ground

115 × 149 cm

Oil on canvas

Est. 30,000 – 55,000 €

2025
Sotheby's · Paris
Deposition of Christ

Antwerp School

Deposition of Christ

75.5 × 96 cm

Panel

Est. 20,000 – 30,000 €

c. 1500–1530
MuseumRijksmuseum · Amsterdam
Lamentation (SK-A-4488)

After Hugo van der Goes

Lamentation (SK-A-4488)

84 × 105 cm

Panel

Tradition 1 — close to the lost original. High-quality, expressive faces, fine detail.

c. 1500
MuseumMSK · Ghent
Lamentation (1951-M)

After Hugo van der Goes

Lamentation (1951-M)

43.6 × 56.5 cm

Panel

Tradition 1 — "Exceptionally fine quality, painted by someone very close to the master."

c. 1500
MuseumBowes Museum · Barnard Castle
Lamentation (B.M.47)

After Hugo van der Goes

Lamentation (B.M.47)

87.5 × 117.5 cm

Panel

Tradition 2 — described as "very different" from the Naples/Ghent/Amsterdam group. Same visual lineage as the painting studied. Covered in black paint in 1580 to protect from Calvinist iconoclasts.

c. 1450–1500
MuseumMusee du Louvre · Paris
Lamentation (RF 1505)

After Hugo van der Goes

Lamentation (RF 1505)

54.3 × 71.5 cm

Panel

Tradition 1 — Friedlander 23b. "Mediocre but one of the most faithful in its sculptural spirit."

c. 1475–1480
MuseumChrist Church · Oxford
Virgin and Saint John

Hugo van der Goes — fragment, possibly autograph

Virgin and Saint John

42 × 46.1 cm

Oil on canvas

The only surviving fragment possibly painted by Hugo van der Goes himself

c. 1475–1500
MuseumMuseo di Capodimonte · Naples
Lamentation

After Hugo van der Goes

Lamentation

54 × 72 cm

Panel

Tradition 1 — Friedlander 23a, the reference version. First copy on which Friedlander (1904) restored the attribution to Van der Goes.

url to add
c. 1500
MuseumMusee municipal · Cambrai
Descente de Croix

After Hugo van der Goes

Descente de Croix

Panel

Early 16th c.
MuseumDurham University · Durham
Lamentation (inv. 18.725)

After Hugo van der Goes

Lamentation (inv. 18.725)

Panel

url to add
c. 1451–1500
MuseumMusee des Beaux-Arts · Tournai
Lamentation (inv. 281)

After Hugo van der Goes

Lamentation (inv. 281)

99 × 123 cm

Oil on panel

Exhibited at the 1902 Bruges Primitives exhibition. Tournai holds two near-identical versions.

url to add

Now consider this panel

The painting in question

RectoVerso

Lamentation of Christ
after Hugo van der Goes

Attribution17th-century Flemish, circle / school of Hugo van der Goes
SubjectLamentation — 6 figures, ornamental gold ground
SupportOak panel
Dimensions50 × 65 cm (panel) · 62 × 77 cm (frame)
ConservationParqueted — crossed wooden battens, verso
Inscription"Janssens" — verso
ProvenanceFamily collection · lot 03059 · 520 F.

The parqueting alone — a costly, specialised intervention — tells us this panel was considered worth preserving.

Sources

Hampel Auctions Munich · Christie's New York & London · Sotheby's Paris · Gazette Drouot · Vanderkindere Brussels · Artcurial Beurret Bailly · Friedländer, Early Netherlandish Painting IV, 1969, n°23 · Dhanens, Hugo van der Goes, Fonds Mercator, 1998, pp. 181–183